Malaysian Tamils = Malays ( Almost ) - Part 2

NOTE : I think not twice but more than ten time before post this article . Because , base on some senior bloggers , my previous post very much provoking and today's blogging atmosphere not save enough for this kind of post . I'm not discussing about any sensitive issue , but using very subtle and critical facts as examples to show the existing similarities between Malays and Malaysian Tamils . CONTINUE READ THIS ARTICLE IF YOU OPEN MINDED ENOUGH , AS A TRUE MALAYSIAN:

This article is the continuation of yesterday's post "Malaysian Tamils = Malays ( Almost )" . But first come first , today's talk of the country " Badawi(PM) will retire march 2009 , about five months from now . He will be replaced by Najib , current DPM . Back the topic , Thanks for all my readers , and commentators who write a short( actually very long , lol ) and constructive comments base on yesterdays article . In the comments , the discussion topic been diverted from main title to somewhere comparing which school is better for build True Malaysians . Even thou diverted , yet i am really happy to discuse a good topic with my commentators . See the bright sight , i get know that , there are many readers out there ready to discuss about which school is best to build true Malaysians, SK or SJK . Wonderful , i got an idea to write an article , title , " SK Vs SJK - TRUE MALAYSIANS" , coming soon to your nearest townguy's blog , lol , really .

Here comes the case study of today ( continuation of yesterday's article ), another most significant similarities between Malays and Malaysian Tamils is , "Always Not Enough" , in Malay "Selalu Tak Cukup" .

As all Malaysian well aware , Malays(Bumiputra) of this country entitled with special prevelages , which know as "Hak Istimewa Bumiputra" . This special prevelage been stated in Malaysian constitution , Article 153 .Base on this article . In my opinion the special treatment( Hak Istimewa Bumiputra ) can be divided into tangible( official ) and intangible( unofficial ) form . Let us don't discuss about the intangible form , because it usually can be field in you normal life if you are not a bumiputra and quite sensitive to discussed about . Tangible hak bumiputra covers every aspect of human life , from buying home to admition for university and do a own business . After New Economy policy launched in , this Hak Istimewa Bumiputra been enforce more aggressively to improve the social level of Malays in this country . Everything done by government for Malays like Spoon feeding . Malaysia's Ex-PM Tun Dr.Mahathir have once stated in his speech , " Orang melayu disediakan semua yang dipelukan untuk maju , macam makanan yang sedia untuk dimakan , government dah pun cuma hingga suap makanan yang disediakan , tapi , orang melayu yang tidak mahu makan " . Many Malays angry with his statement , but he din't give a dame about that because he angry with Malays who reluctant to improve their self . This shows how spoon feeding the government to Malays all this time , but yet you and i can see , Malays say , they not enough with what they get as Malays(Bumiputra) and involve in demonstration against the goverment it self . Please make this clear here ,im not questioning Artcle 153 , just taking this issue to compare Malays with Malaysian Tamils . So don't be sensitive and assume that im questioning Hak Istimewa Bumiputra . The malays reluctant to improve fast ennough with sea wide apportunities . What the other races in Malaysia doing at the same time line , the opprtunity not wide open as Malays , yet they squezee through small opprtunities , work hard and improve their life style , aspecialy Chinese community .

Now we look at Malaysian Tamils , before i start talk , are you already start see the similarities ? yes/no , lol . Malaysian Tamils , largest ethnic group in Malaysia Indians .They do not have special prevelage as Malays . Becuse they are the largest ethnic group in Malaysia Indians( thirt largest Race in Malaysia ) , all the the benefit from goverment will reach this ethnic before disperse to other Malaysian Indian ethnic such as Malaysian Malayalee , Malaysian Telegu or Punjabi . You may turn back and ask , how it is possible? It is possible , if you aware , most of Malaysia Indian representatives( mostly politicians) are Tamils . In this 21st centuty im not provoking any Indian ethnic issue , but just take this whole fact as an case study to show the similarities between Malays and Malaysia Tamils . Back to story , the benefits which reach Malaysia Indian Community , mostly enjoy my Malaysian Tamils becuse of thier advantage as majority . The benefits are financial aid for tamil schools, vocational training , political power allocation , and etc . I make this point clear again , the goverment does not allocate the benefits specially for Malaysian Tamils , but they allocate the benefit for whole Indian community , but i saying the Tamils get more benefits because Malaysian Tamils are majority compare to other Malaysian Indian ethnics . Lately , i read a news in The Star newspaper, stating that , Vise Human Resource Minister( representative of MIC ) reveal , goverment allocated about 900 vocational training seats for Indians , but just about 250 Indian students register for the course . The goverment , doing their best for Malaysian Indians , but we our self not aware of this opportunities . End up pointing our fingers fowards goverment and accuse them for not doing enough for our community . Here i say WE , means , Malaysian Tamils . What other Malaysian Indian ethnics such as Malaysian Malayalee , Malaysian Telegu , or Punjabi( sikh ) did in the same timeline where we busy accusing the goverment . They aware of their position as minority , use well the small opportunities , work hard and develop their life style . Good example , we can look at Malaysian Punjabi ( sikh ) community today.

Hope by now , you understand a bit atleast about the complex issue which i tried my level best to explain to all of you . As a conclusion , Malays and Malaysian Tamils demonstrate another similiraties which is , fail to identifie and utilise the oppotunities which the goverment provide , and at the same time , lack behind other races and ethnic . Sorry to be sound very racist or ethnist , lol , since last two days . All the fact above , i only took and talk about it just as an case study to explain the similarities between Malays and Malaysian Tamils . I my self is a Malaysian Tamil , and True Malaysian , just take this article as an exercise for your mind to understand the complexity of races and ethnic . Thanks for the support .

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Agreed, We Malaysian Tamils especially likes to complain and accuse others instead of analysing our mistakes. I think all the other Indians (Malayalees, Telugus, Gujaratis, Punjabis etc.) are doing much better than us (Tamils) because they do not depend on chances to be given to them but instead they explore for opportunities and work hard to achieve success.

Anonymous said...

to murthi :

ya bro , we(tamils) should open our eyes and look for opportunity, push a side typical sentiments , dont bother about what others will tell about us , and work hard towards improve ourself , and our community in whole .

Anonymous said...

Very childish and disturbing comparison(part 1 & 2) you've made there buddy.

The reason why "other Malaysian Indian ethnics such as Malaysian Malayalee , Malaysian Telegu , or Punjabi( sikh )" are much much more United thn the Tamil speaking ones is due to the fact tht they dnt have the numbers to survive current government policies which allocate very little percentage of everything for indians as whole. Reason to this is because almost all indians in this country prefer to mingle with people whom speak the same language. By having such an attitude we are further dividing ourselves.

One perfect example would be the 1st 2 comments above;

.....doing much better than us (Tamils) because ....

....ya bro , we(tamils) should open our eyes and look for opportunity, push .....

People such as yourselves make it seem like Tamil, Malayalam,Punjabi and Telegu are all races instead of Languages. Dividing each other based on mother tongue is the most stupidest thing ever.

This is Malaysia, NOT INDIA. for a country of 1 billion+ population where each state has its own major language where over 100s of millions speak it, dividing each other based on language MAY seem acceptable or unavoidable.

But looks like whn the British dragged us here, not only did we bring our food and culture, but also the stinking mindsets.

Wht might seem to work in India WILL NOT work for an Indian population of 2,100,000/ 25,000,000, where government policies dont favour Indians as a whole.

And Townguy, before you start shooting at why there are so many tamil schools instead of other languages, go and learn the history of Indian immigration to malaysia pre and post Merdeka. History has its toll on why things are wht they are now. Now only schools, but basically everything related to the Indian community.

So pls, dont compare Indians ( tamil speaking) with the Malays.Firstly, everyone has to change their mindsets, AND THT INCLUDES YOU. But i do agree with you, tht Indians in Malaysia have to work harder in order to achieve greatness, not only tamil speaking ones , but ALL.

Anonymous said...

thanks for the comment the truth :

i know my part one and two quite childish as you say . I my mind , i just taking it as an example , not more than that , for sure im not a person who differentiate Malaysian Indians base on their mother tongue .

I learn history( A+ SPM ) , lol . My close friend is a Malayalee , but every time i saw him as a Hindu and Indian , and not Malayalee . Think shows that , all the fact i discussed in my article , just there to be a examples , just EXAMPLES .

Thanks again for tour support and time the truth

Anonymous said...

@townguy

well, thn i must have been clearly mistaken about you. though i may not agree with your opinions here, but,you have explained this article in quite a detailed manner,so respect for tht!

Anonymous said...

Bro,

Although we are divided into sub-ethnics in this country, but that doesn't mean that we are not being united at all. We are being united but at the same time, there are some retards who think that their particular ethnic is much superior compared to other ethnics, and upholding their exclusive appearance, skin color and etc etc. Seriously, this kind of people are plain retards!

Nice and detailed case study. Keep it up!